Do I need a realtor to sell my house for cash?

Most Tampa Bay homeowners assume they need a realtor to sell their house. That's because the only people who tell them otherwise are people trying to buy their house, which makes the advice feel suspect. So let's set the table honestly. We are cash buyers. We benefit when a seller doesn't use an agent. Knowing that, here's the clean version of when an agent is the right call, and when they're a tax on your proceeds you don't need to pay.

Florida law doesn't require you to use one. That's the legal answer. The practical answer takes about three minutes.

1. The 6% commission math (and why it's the whole question)

Standard real estate commission in Tampa Bay sits at 5 to 6% of the sale price. On a $300,000 Brandon home that's $15,000 to $18,000. On a $450,000 St. Pete home that's $22,500 to $27,000. The commission is split between the listing agent (your side) and the buyer's agent (their side), each typically getting 2.5 to 3%.

Post-2024, the rules changed. Buyers can now pay their own agent directly, which means in some cases you only owe the listing-side commission of 2.5 to 3%. That's still $7,500 to $9,000 on a $300,000 home. The number you owe an agent is real money, and it always comes off your net. So the question becomes: what does the agent return for that $7,500 to $27,000?

2. When a realtor earns their commission

A good agent in Tampa Bay creates value in three specific places, and the math works when all three apply to your situation:

• The home is in good condition. Roof under 10 years, working AC, kitchen and baths in decent shape, no foundation issues. The kind of home where retail buyers can imagine moving in next weekend.
• You have time. 60 to 120 days minimum from list to close. A good agent uses that runway to drive multiple offers and push your number $5,000 to $25,000 above what you'd get without representation.
• You can host the process. Showings, open houses, photographers, contingencies, inspection negotiations, the back-and-forth. None of it is hostile, but all of it costs energy.

If those three boxes check, hire the agent. The commission is real, but the price uplift and the protection a good agent provides usually outweigh it. We say this against our own interest, but it's the truth.

3. When a realtor is a drag on your proceeds

The math flips fast in any of these situations:

• You're selling to a cash buyer who's already named. The agent's job is to find you a buyer. If the buyer is already at your door, you're paying for a service that's already done.
• The home needs $20,000+ in repairs. Retail buyers either won't qualify (financing won't close on a damaged property) or will demand you fix it before close. Cash buyers will buy as-is. Why a $40K foundation report doesn't mean a $40K hit on price explains how this lands.
• You have a tight timeline. Job relocation, divorce, pre-foreclosure, estate sale where heirs live out of state. The 60-to-120-day retail timeline doesn't fit the calendar you're working with.
• The property is tenant-occupied or hoarder-condition. Realtors generally won't list these. Cash buyers buy them weekly.
• You don't want strangers in the house. Recent divorce, deceased parent, anything where MLS photos and open houses feel wrong.

In any of these cases, the agent commission becomes a tax with no offsetting return. Side-by-side comparison of net proceeds in each scenario is here.

4. The numbers that usually decide it

Here's a clean comparison we've run for Tampa Bay sellers more times than we can count. A 1,400-square-foot Hillsborough home that needs a roof and a kitchen update.

The retail-fixed path nets the most money on paper. But it requires $40,000 of capital up front for repairs, four months of holding costs (roughly $7,200), and the patience for a financing-contingent close that has a 1-in-8 chance of falling through. Subtract those from $272,000 and the gap closes fast. For sellers without that capital or that patience, the cash path is mathematically equal or better, on top of being faster and certain.

5. The middle path: hire an agent only for the paperwork

If you have a buyer (us, or anyone else) but want a Florida-licensed agent reviewing the contract before you sign, you can hire one on a flat fee. Some Tampa Bay agents will handle a transaction-only role for $1,500 to $3,000 instead of a 3% commission. They don't market the house. They review the contract, attend closing, and protect your paperwork. Most agents don't advertise this option, but most will agree to it if you ask. It's the cleanest way to get professional eyes on the deal without paying for a service you don't need.

6. The straight call

If your Pinellas County home is move-in ready and you have time, hire a good agent and let them work. If your home needs work, you're under any kind of pressure, or you already know your buyer, skip the listing and sell direct. Local cash buyer vs. iBuyer is a separate comparison, and the answer there matters too.

If you want to know what a Tampa Bay cash buyer would actually pay for your house before you decide, that's a 24-hour answer. Address pill is here.

Frequently asked questions